CAGAYAN DE ORO CITY — Members of the Upper Puerto CARP Beneficiaries Association are appealing for an urgent review of land title cancellation proceedings and a demolition order that could displace families recognized as agrarian reform beneficiaries.Represented by association president Gemma D. Herrera, the group maintains that its members received land titles through official government processes.
They are seeking answers over the cancellation of their Certificates of Land Ownership Award (CLOAs), which they claim was pursued without proper notice or a meaningful opportunity to be heard.The dispute dates back to a March 27, 2007, Supreme Court ruling in Department of Agrarian Reform v. Oroville Development Corporation, which addressed the coverage of approximately 48.89 hectares in Maitum, Upper Puerto, under the Comprehensive Agrarian Reform Program (CARP).
The Court found that the properties remained agricultural in classification and that their inclusion in the city’s potential urban expansion area did not, by itself, exempt them from agrarian reform coverage.According to the association, a Notice of Coverage was annotated on the mother titles in August 2008.
However, the group questions why only around nine hectares of the disputed land were reportedly processed for distribution to beneficiaries, while approximately 39.8 hectares allegedly remained under private claimants.The association is also challenging subsequent proceedings before the Department of Agrarian Reform (DAR).
An exemption order issued on December 19, 2024, granted an application to exempt the land from CARP coverage, while another order dated May 16, 2025, directed the cancellation of beneficiaries’ CLOAs. The association contends that its members were not properly notified of the proceedings that directly affected their land rights.Since engaging its legal team, the association has filed petitions and motions seeking relief, an audit of land records, and a suspension of implementation measures while its challenges are considered.
It has also called on DAR to reconcile the Supreme Court ruling, the Notice of Coverage, the subsequent title issuances, and the exemption order.The group further reports that residents have been told to leave the area and that a proposed relocation site is not yet suitable for residence.
It is asking authorities to review the relocation arrangements, assess applicable disturbance-compensation provisions, and consider lawful protective measures against displacement while pending matters are evaluated.The association emphasized that its appeal is not intended to prejudge the legal proceedings or deny other claimants their right to pursue their cases. Instead, it is calling for transparency, due process, and a fair opportunity for affected beneficiaries to defend their interests before any irreversible action is taken.










