MANILA, Philippines — Legal and digital rights advocates are raising concerns over proposed restrictions on young people’s social media use, warning that mandatory identity verification could expose Filipinos to wider government surveillance, data privacy risks, and digital exclusion.
The concerns come as lawmakers prepare to reconcile the House of Representatives and Senate versions of the proposed Safe Media Access and Responsible Technology for Kids in Digital Spaces (SMART KIDS) Act, which seeks to regulate young people’s access to social media and impose additional requirements on online platforms.
Former Department of Information and Communications Technology (DICT) Undersecretary Jeffrey Ian Dy warned that requiring government-issued identification to access social media could create privacy and surveillance concerns, particularly for Filipinos who lack official identification documents.
Dy questioned the proposed collection and management of users’ personal information, emphasizing the need for clear safeguards on which government agencies could access the records and how the information would be used.
He also recalled that in 2022, Malacañang vetoed the original version of the SIM Card Registration Act after provisions requiring real-name registration on social media were inserted into the measure, citing concerns over government intrusion and surveillance.
Meanwhile, Yuki Abion, public policy associate of the Sigla Research Center, warned that mandatory collection of sensitive personal information could compromise privacy and deepen the digital divide, particularly in areas with limited internet infrastructure.
Abion also questioned whether existing age-verification mechanisms could effectively protect children while respecting users’ rights to data privacy and security.Doreen Murata, digital advocacy co-lead of the Child Rights Network, stressed that protecting children online should not come at the expense of their rights to participation, information, education, and self-expression.
She emphasized the importance of making digital platforms safer for young people rather than simply restricting their access.
The advocates argued that a blanket restriction could also limit legitimate uses of social media, including academic collaboration, creative expression, and civic engagement, without directly addressing harmful online content and other digital threats.
They called for a more balanced approach to online child protection that considers both safety and the fundamental rights of young people.










